Stop Promoting People Into Failure with Andrew Amrhein

Your best framer becomes a foreman and struggles. Your sharpest estimator becomes a project manager and stalls. Your most reliable staff accountant becomes controller, and six months later the reconciliations are a mess. Sound familiar?

There is a name for this. It is called the Peter Principle: people get promoted until they reach a role they cannot do. In construction, it happens constantly, and it costs firms real money in blown projects, burned-out people, and stalled growth.

On this episode of Builders, Budgets & Beers, Reece sat down with Andrew Amrhein, an equity partner at Precision SME Group with 18 years of consulting experience across more than 500 companies, to unpack the one conversation he thinks construction is not having enough: the difference between doing the work and managing the work, and why the missing layer between vision and results is almost always management.

The one conversation construction is not having

When Reece asked Andrew what topic gets overlooked most in the industry, his answer surprised even him: connecting numbers to strategy in a way that is meaningful to the person doing the work.

Most firms think they already do this. They map revenue to goals all the time. But Andrew’s point is sharper. You can have a visionary leader casting a bold direction, and six months later nothing has moved, because nobody translated that vision into concrete steps for the people expected to execute it.

That translation is the job of management. And it is the piece most construction companies skip.

The eight levels of work, explained

Andrew’s framework comes from Elliott Jaques (pronounced “Jacks,” a Canadian who studied organizations for over 50 years). Jaques identified eight distinct levels of work, and the core insight is this: getting great at one level does not prepare you for the level above it. Each level requires a different kind of thinking.

Here is how the first five levels play out in a construction business:

Level 1 is doing the work. You are using a physical tool, a hammer, a keyboard, a design program. Decisions are either/or: I can do this, or I can do that.

Level 2 is making sure the work gets done. This is the senior craftsman who does the work and coordinates others at the same time. You know you are here when you are using and building checklists and starting to coordinate tasks.

Level 3 is designing the systems people work within. This is the first level that separates from the work itself. Level 3 creates the checklist, Level 2 uses it, Level 1 does what is on it. This level owns root cause analysis, process mapping, and making a department run better.

Level 4 is integration. Instead of going deep on one department, you go horizontal across them. If something happens in sales, you understand why it cannot happen in operations, and you connect the two.

Level 5 is external. Vision, values, market positioning, branding, pricing. This is where the company looks outward.

Andrew’s warning: none of these levels prepares you for the one above it. Getting really good at building a home does not prepare you to coordinate crews. Getting good at running a department does not prepare you to integrate across departments. Yet firms promote as if each rung automatically qualifies you for the next.

The Grand Canyon rule: every layer is equal

One reason management gets dismissed in construction is that it does not look like “real” work. Nobody is swinging a hammer, so nobody sees the value.

Andrew flips that with a simple image. Stand at the Grand Canyon and look at the layers of rock. Is any single layer more important than the others? No. They are all holding the whole thing up. Jaques deliberately called these levels “stratums” rather than “levels” so people would not rank them and assume higher means better.

Level 3 and Level 4 management work is not overhead to be cut. It is the layer that turns strategy into action. Without it, you get vision that never lands and quarterly execution meetings where everyone is running their own private strategy.

Projects, not promotions

So how do you know if someone can handle the next level before you hand them the job? Andrew’s rule is one of the most practical takeaways of the episode: projects, not promotions.

Do not promote and hope. Give people a project that requires the thinking of the next level, then watch what happens. You get real evidence instead of a guess.

A few ways to run this:

• Let someone be foreman for a day on the right kind of job, then give feedback.
• Ask a rising team member to run a meeting.
• Hand two people a real problem: “Design me a better way for foremen to return unused equipment and materials to the shop.” The solution might be great or it might be terrible, but either way you learn whether they can do Level 3 work.
• Want to know if someone is ready to supervise? Ask them to build a detailed checklist for how a process should run. If they can think at that level, they can oversee others doing it.

Andrew’s rule of thumb: do not promote anyone without at least three project confirmations. When Jack Welch left GE, he already had people doing his job before the board picked the next CEO. That is projects proving capability before the title ever changes.

How to make numbers actually mean something

People want four things at work: Where are we going? How do we get there? How can I help? What is in it for me? Most construction firms are strong on strategy (the first two) and sometimes on incentives (the last one), but weak on the middle translation.

Andrew’s example makes it concrete. Instead of announcing “we are going to hit $30 million in revenue,” a manager connects it to the individual: “We did $19 million last year. We are going to $25 million this year and $30 million next year. Because of that, I need you ready to be a project manager by June.” Suddenly the number means something to the person hearing it. That is management doing its job.

What managers are actually for

If a manager is not swinging a hammer, what are they for? Andrew’s answer: a manager is responsible for the output of other people, and they earn that role by bringing value to the people above and below them.

That value shows up in a few specific ways:

Prioritizing for the team. Never make your people prioritize on their own. You are the lifeguard in the chair with perspective the crew on the ground does not have. When the tide goes way out, the kids see free seashells and the parents on the beach cannot tell low tide from a tsunami. The person in the elevated chair can. Managers see what their team cannot.

Making the hard call. You only have one boom lift. Do not make two project managers argue over it. Two planes need to take off in a snowstorm and there is one spare, one needs de-icing and one needs a new wheel. The pilots do not want to make that call. The manager steps up, decides, and owns it.

Owning the decision so people speak up. When nobody talks in a meeting, it is often because they are afraid the outcome will get pinned on them. Andrew’s move: say “If this goes wrong, it is my fault. What I need from you is honest feedback.” He has watched a room physically relax and start giving real input once the fear of blame is gone.

Fix the system, not the blame

Andrew closed on the idea he is most passionate about: lead people, fix systems. When something goes wrong, the wrong question is “whose fault was it?” The right question is “how did the system allow this to happen, and how do we make the wrong thing impossible?”

Think about a gas station. You physically cannot put a diesel nozzle into a gasoline car. The system prevents the mistake. In sales, Andrew error-proofs bids by running confirmation calls so owners do not forget the appointment. In manufacturing, a small arm on the conveyor flips every bolt face-up so none arrive wrong. That is respecting people: design the work so doing the wrong thing is not possible, rather than hunting for someone to blame.

The takeaway for construction leaders

Strategy and execution get all the attention. Management, the layer that connects them, gets slept on because it does not look like value-producing work. But it is where most of the value is actually created. If your vision keeps stalling, the gap is probably not effort or talent. It is the missing management layer that translates the plan into something real for each person doing the job.

Start with one shift this week: before your next promotion, hand that person a project first.

About the guest

Andrew Amrhein is an equity partner at Precision SME Group (strategy, management, and execution), where he helps contractors and small businesses get better at getting better through lean, Lean Six Sigma, and levels-of-work planning. You can find him at precision-sme.com, connect with him on LinkedIn, or reach him directly at andrew@precision-sme.com.

Want more real talk on construction finance and operations? Listen to Builders, Budgets & Beers, brought to you by Adaptive, the construction finance platform that automates back-office accounting so your team can focus on building. Learn more at adaptive.build.